Clothes mentor vs. Plato’s closet

These days, everyone is looking for a way to make money from their unwanted clothes. The best thing you can do with those extra pairs of shoes or designer dresses in your closet? Sell them! Clothes Mentor and Plato’s closet are good resale stores that buy gently used clothing and offer great payment rates, so it doesn’t matter what type of item(s)you decide on selling. There’ll be an opportunity waiting just around the corner (plus cash).

It can be hard to know where to go when you need to sell or buy clothes. There are a few options in the area, but what’s the difference between Clothes Mentor and Plato’s Closet?

When comparing clothes mentor and Plato’s closet, it’s important to know the key differences between the two.

  1. Clothes mentor mainly focuses on adult wear and accessories. Clothes mentor has a wider range of brands they accept. If you have something specific in mind or are looking for a high-end piece, clothes mentor is likely your best bet.
  2. Plato’s closet mainly focuses on teens’ and young adults’ clothing and accessories.

However, they both offer convenient locations. Comparison between the two depends on several factors. Here we break it down for you.

Comparison based on the type of clothing.

Both stores have a guideline for what type of clothing they accept (gender, brand, trending clothes), and they can be quite picky. Both stores ensure that the items they accept must be trending and in a good state; anything from over a year and a half is not accepted.

Clothes Mentor buys everything from shoes and accessories, all of which come in sizes 0-26, with a target audience of 25-year-olds up through 55. They look for brands like Adidas, Louis Vuitton, Michael Kors, and more.

Plato’s Closet specializes in buying men’s and women’s clothes and accessories for teens/young adults to shop from sizes 0-30 for females or 28 – 40 for males! They look for brands like Adidas, Forever 21, Pink by Victoria’s secret, and more.

Comparison based on pricing

Both stores give you one-third of the original retail value. For $100 clothes, they will charge you $30 from buyers but only pay around $10 for it themselves.

Both stores pay in cash for trades. However, you can also receive store credit, apply the price for use on in-store purchases, or a voucher to use at a later time.

Comparison based on convenience

Clothes Mentor has about 150 store locations across 29 states, most of which are located east of the Mississippi River, making it convenient for people in those regions. You can easily find a clothes mentor store using their store locator.

Plato’s closet is typically more convenient because they have locations all over the area. Plato’s closet has about 500 stores across Canada and the US. Using their store locator, you can easily find Plato’s closet store near you.

Comparison based on the process of selling

Style, the health of the clothes, and the brand matter most to both stores. In the next step, the items will be thoroughly checked for any imperfections before a quotation is given.

How do I choose between Clothes Mentor and Plato’s closet?

Best Consignment Store To Sell Clothes

Which option is right for you depends on what you’re looking for. If you’re looking to get rid of many clothes, Clothes Mentor is the better option. Plato’s Closet is the better option if you’re looking to sell a few nicer pieces.

Which store you choose depends on what you’re looking for. Plato’s closet is your best bet if you’re looking for high-end designer pieces. If you’re looking for more affordable options or something more eclectic, clothes mentor is better.

Either way, both stores are great options for scoring stylish clothes at a fraction of the price! Clothes Mentor and Plato’s closet are great places to find gently used clothing.


Are both stores the same?

No, while there are some similarities between Plato’s Closet and clothes mentor, their differences in the process make them two different unique stores.

Does Plato’s closet accept target clothes?

Plato’s Closet only accepts clothing that is at least a year old. They don’t accept Walmart clothes but will take Target Mossimo Brand items instead! Because they believe in keeping up with trends and staying fashionable!

Do both stores pay for clothes?

Yes, as long as the clothes intended for sale are gently used and trendy, both stores will pay you to resell the clothes.


So which of these two clothing stores is the best? Both have their pros and cons; they also offer great services. Regarding brand preference when it comes down to just choosing one store over another – this might seem obvious since they specialize in different types. However, the earlier mentioned factors are worth considering before making your final decision, including what type of clothes you want to sell, pricing & process involved.